top of page

After the Announcement: Managing the Uncertainty of Leadership Change

Debbie Braden
Nov 9
4 min read
Woman sitting alone at a long boardroom table surrounded by empty chairs, waiting for a meeting to begin

Anyone who has started a diet or a new exercise regimen knows change is hard. This is true even though we’re willing to start the change and want the results. Diet and exercise consistently top New Year’s resolution lists. That’s why gyms are stuffed in January and quieter by March.


So why do companies think a memo and org chart is enough when it comes to leadership changes in an organization? A leadership transition is harder because it’s a change that is chosen for people. But leaders expect impacted employees to keep momentum, adopting the change faster than any change they choose for themselves.


Leadership change is the current operating environment. Employers announced more than 617,000 cuts through October (1) on top of the 1.2 million we saw in 2025. (2) Beneath those cuts is internal restructuring. In private equity, AlixPartners research shows 65% of firms see CEO turnover during the hold period. (3)


The impact hits hardest in the layers underneath a leadership announcement—ripples of uncertainty from employees who don’t know what new priorities, new rules or new people will come next.


You may have heard me say this before—people can handle bad news. What they can’t handle is not knowing. And science backs this up. 


I recently read a 2016 study from University College London where they set up a computer game in which participants turned over digital rocks. (4) Some rocks hid a snake, some hid nothing. When the participant uncovered a snake, they received a mild shock. Researchers shifted the odds of finding a snake, so the uncertainty level went up and down throughout the game, measuring the self-reported stress levels, along with sweat and pupil size. Stress peaked when there was a 50/50 chance of receiving a shock. Interestingly, when participants knew for sure there would or wouldn’t be a shock, stress was lowest. The TLDR of this is stress followed the uncertainty, not the pain. It was not knowing that was more stressful.


Researchers also learned that people whose stress tracked the uncertainty most closely were better at predicting which rocks had snakes, which isn’t surprising when we think about fight flight or freeze. We are wired for stress to help us read when there is danger. That’s particularly interesting when you put this in context of leadership changes. It doesn’t really matter if the leader removed is trusted or not. They were predictable. People knew how to work with them or work around them. The new leader takes that map away.


The same holds true no matter the leader’s level—from VP to GM to frontline, the expectations and the questions are the same. Those changes get less attention, sometimes they don’t even have an announcement, but their impact remains. Employees are left questioning what gets noticed, what gets rewarded and where they fit in what’s coming.

When I worked in corporate, I worked for a company that had a big leadership change. One appointment reshaped the reporting structure bringing new inherited teams under their responsibility that created some overlapping roles and teams underneath. This would have been the ultimate 50/50 rock in the UCL game because the uncertainty wasn’t just from the leadership change, but what the restructuring would bring.


In the first 90 days, 1:1’s with new leaders were cancelled, cut short or started late. Then came layoffs and a memo of its own with an accompanying or chart. It just confirmed what the cancelled meetings had already told them.


Sometimes changes are needed whether employees want them or not. What matters is how they’re made. Every leadership change hands employees a new rock to turn over. Leaders decide how long they will leave employees guessing.


As a former internal communicator, I know a well thought out organizational announcement and accompanying org chart are important. That’s where the change starts. It’s what comes after that decides whether you get momentum from the change. People still need to know what’s expected now, what gets rewarded and where they fit in, and they’ll figure that out from what the leader does next.


The bottom line is leadership changes need to be treated like any other major change. Listen to what people are saying and check whether it’s being adopted. The bigger the change, the more it needs.


 

This article was written by a human. The perspective is mine—based on my questions, observations, and experience.


I use AI as a thought partner to challenge my thinking, identify gaps, and surface perspectives I hadn’t considered. Anything that comes from AI goes back through me. I push back, verify, and decide what gets included. I only use data from primary sources. They are clearly identified in my writing with links for you to dig in. Before publishing, I run my final draft through AI again for spelling and grammar. Typos and grammar mistakes still happen. I'm not perfect and neither is AI.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page